Research & Insights

Raise Strategies That Keep Your Best People

Employees who get a raise are half as likely to quit. But most small companies don't have a formal raise strategy. Here's what the data shows about what works.

Nov 17, 2026

Employees who get a raise are half as likely to quit. But most small companies don't have a formal raise strategy. Here's what the data shows about what works.

Most small businesses don't have a raise process

Two-thirds of Justworks customers offer at least one type of annual raise. That's a solid foundation, but there's an important caveat: only 50% of companies with fewer than 10 employees have a standardized process. The rest operate ad hoc, informally, and inconsistently.

261103 AODigital Website Report RaiseStrategies HowCompaniesSetRaises

This matters because employees notice. When raise decisions lack transparency and consistency, it drives turnover.

The impact of raises (by the numbers)

Employees who receive a raise are 50% less likely to quit in the next 12 months compared to those who don't. That's a significant difference in retention.

261103 AODigital Website Report RaiseStrategies Impact

But the size of the raise matters. Raises that don't keep up with inflation underperform. Employees who receive raises above the inflation rate are 14% less likely to quit than those receiving raises below inflation.

What raises look like across company sizes

The pattern is clear when you look at how raise practices vary by company size.

The percentage of companies offering annual raises increases with company size. Smaller companies are more likely to use a mix of raise types (market adjustments, promotion-based increases, bonuses, spot awards) without a consistent annual cycle. Mid-sized companies start standardizing on annual raises. Larger companies have formal processes with multiple raise vehicles and predictable cadences.

This reflects a natural progression: flexibility works at smaller scale, but structure becomes necessary as headcount grows. This is big for small businesses, since consistency attracts top talent.

261103 AODigital Website Report RaiseStrategies CompanySize

The complex calculus behind every raise

When companies set compensation, they're weighing multiple factors at once: base salary, benefits, retirement contributions, bonuses, PTO, and paid family leave. Each of these is part of total compensation.

261103 AODigital Website Report RaiseStrategies ComplexCalculus

Adding to the complexity, 20% of Justworks customers say getting accurate market data on compensation is difficult. Most SMBs don't have a systematic approach to staying competitive on compensation. Raises happen, but they're not rooted in market reality.

How to build a raise strategy (without overcomplicating it)

You don't need to overcomplicate this. Start by following four steps:

  1. Decide your cadence. Do you give raises annually? When someone is promoted? Ad hoc but documented? Pick one and stick with it.

  2. Establish your criteria. What drives a raise? Performance? Market rate adjustments? Inflation? Length of tenure? Name which factors matter to you.

  3. Know your benchmarks. What are people making in your roles, at your company size, in your market? If you don't know this, you're missing critical information.

  4. Communicate it. Tell people how they can earn more. Be transparent about the process.

Once you have these in place, you can choose which mix of raise types work best for your business:

  • Annual cost-of-living adjustments show you're tracking inflation

  • Promotion raises signal that growth and advancement are real

  • Market adjustments kick in when market rates shift

  • Spot bonuses give you flexibility to retain someone at a critical moment

The retention math

The cost to replace an employee is typically 40-200% of their salary. Your typical raise budget is 2-4% annually.

Even a 3% raise is cheaper than replacing someone. For a $60,000 employee, a 3% raise costs $1,800 per year. Replacing them could cost $24,000 to $120,000.

For a $100,000 employee, a 4% raise costs $4,000. Replacing them could cost $40,000 to $200,000.

Raises are an investment in stability, not an expense.

261103 AODigital Website Report RaiseStrategies RaisevsReplacement

Justworks can help you benchmark roles, set raise budgets, and communicate your strategy transparently. Schedule a conversation to explore how we can support your compensation strategy.

Disclaimer: The Justworks data and insights relied upon and provided herein are based on an aggregated and de-identified subset of customers. This information is intended for general informational purposes only. These insights may not be representative of the broader market or any specific industry at large. Justworks makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, regarding the accuracy, completeness, or future applicability of the Justworks data or national data insights provided.