Open Enrollment in 2026: “Planxiety” and the Growing Role of AI
New research from Justworks and The Harris Poll explores how Americans are using AI to navigate “planxiety” and health insurance decisions.

Choosing health insurance can feel overwhelming. Between rising costs, confusing terminology and changing healthcare needs, Americans are navigating important decisions that affect their health, finances and families. And increasingly, they're turning to AI for help.
New research from Justworks conducted by The Harris Poll finds 65% of Americans would be comfortable using AI as a resource when choosing health insurance, suggesting AI is increasingly becoming part of how people navigate a traditionally complex process. At the same time, 12% aren't confident they understand the available plans well enough to choose one that best fits their current life and healthcare needs. The data suggests people see AI as a resource for navigating their options, not a replacement for making the decision themselves.
Key Findings
The findings reveal a growing opportunity to help Americans use AI more effectively during Open Enrollment, not to make their benefits decisions for them, but to better understand their options and ask the questions that matter most.
To help bridge that gap, Justworks is introducing The Open Enrollment Planxiety Help Desk, a limited-time AI resource designed to help employees ask better benefits questions and make benefit selections with greater confidence. Whether they’re new to using AI for support or use it every day, employees can build a personalized, copy-ready prompt for the AI platform of their choice or download an AI skill for more guided benefits support.
“Planxiety” persists: 12% of Americans aren't confident they understand available plans well enough to choose one that fits their current life and healthcare needs, rising to 18% among Gen Z.
Americans are open to AI for benefits help: 65% would be comfortable using AI as a resource when choosing health insurance, including 77% of Gen Z (ages 18-29).
Americans want AI to help decode their options: 37% would be comfortable using AI to compare health plans, while 33% would use it to explain insurance terms they don't understand and 33% to understand potential costs.
Americans still want to remain in control: 24% would be comfortable using AI to recommend a health plan, while just 12% would be comfortable having it make the final decision for them.
Open Enrollment “Planxiety” Is Real
The new research points to a broader challenge: choosing health insurance isn't simply about comparing a list of plans. Americans are trying to determine whether their coverage fits their lives today, and whether it can keep up when their circumstances change.
More than 1 in 10 Americans (12%) say their current health insurance coverage does not meet their needs well.
Fourteen percent aren't confident their current health benefits could meet their needs if they experienced a major life change, such as having a baby, breaking a bone or receiving a complex medical diagnosis.
Those decisions can become even more complicated during major life transitions, whether someone is turning 26 and choosing coverage independently, getting married, preparing for a child or navigating new healthcare needs.
Americans say factors including coverage for prescription medications (42%), affordable monthly premiums (41%), and low deductibles/out-of-pocket costs (37%) would become especially important if their healthcare needs change.
And that uncertainty can contribute to what Justworks calls “planxiety,” the stress and uncertainty that can come with choosing health insurance during Open Enrollment without feeling fully informed about the options.
Employees Are Increasingly Turning to AI for Benefits Help
For some employees, AI is becoming another resource for researching and making sense of health insurance.
Justworks' 2025 Benefit Blindspots Report found that 62% of Zillennials had used AI tools for medical or insurance information, compared with 29% of Gen X and Boomers.
New 2026 research builds on those findings:
52% of Americans who have chosen or plan to choose health insurance through Open Enrollment have used AI to help with the process, including to compare differences between health plans (23%), understand potential costs (21%), explain insurance terms they don't understand (21%) and identify questions they should be asking (19%).
The research also sheds light on where people see AI playing a role in navigating health insurance decisions. Nearly two-thirds of Americans (65%) would be comfortable using AI as a resource when choosing health insurance, including 37% who would use it to compare plans, 33% to explain insurance terms they don't understand, 33% to understand potential costs and 29% to identify questions they should be asking. By comparison, 24% would be comfortable using AI to recommend a health plan and just 12% would be comfortable having it make the final decision for them.
That’s at the heart of Justworks’ approach: AI can be a useful resource for navigating a complicated topic, helping people ask better questions and understand their options, backed by expertise and a partner they can trust.
Start With the Right Questions
Whether you're choosing your first health insurance plan or reassessing coverage after a major life change, asking the right questions can help you make a more informed decision.
For example, someone going through open enrollment might be wondering:
What questions should I ask before adding a partner or dependent to my coverage?
What should I consider if I'm planning to have a baby next year?
What should I consider when comparing plans with different premiums and deductibles?
I'm turning 26 and choosing my own health insurance for the first time. What should I understand before enrolling?
How can I confirm whether my doctors and prescriptions are covered?
Introducing the Planxiety Help Desk: Less Anxiety, More Clarity
The research underscores that health insurance decisions are personal. Someone getting married is likely weighing different considerations than someone managing prescriptions, preparing to have a child, or choosing coverage for the first time.
But knowing where to start, which questions to ask, or how to use AI effectively to make an informed decision, isn't always easy.
Enter The Planxiety Help Desk. This limited-time educational resource helps employees put AI to work on their benefits questions, without handing over the decision.
Designed for different levels of AI familiarity, The Planxiety Help Desk offers two ways to get started:
Prompt Builder: Answer a few simple questions about your life, coverage needs and priorities to generate a personalized, copy-ready prompt for ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or your preferred AI assistant. It's an easy starting point for understanding costs, exploring coverage considerations and identifying the questions worth asking.
Open Enrollment AI Skill: If you use AI skills more regularly, download the skill and use it in a compatible AI assistant for a more guided conversation about your benefits. You can explore important considerations, ask follow-up questions and, if you choose, upload employer plan documents to better understand how different options compare against your priorities.
Two ways to get started. One goal: less planxiety, more clarity.
“Choosing health insurance is a very personal decision, and there isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer,” says David Feinberg, SVP of Risk & Insurance at Justworks. “AI can be a useful tool for helping people cut through some of the complexity, but the real value is in helping them ask better questions and understand what matters most for their own situation. The goal should be to use tools like AI alongside trusted resources, whether that’s your employer, benefits team, insurance carrier or plan documents, so you can feel more confident in the decision you ultimately make.”
A Look Ahead: What's Next for AI at Justworks
The Planxiety Help Desk is a seasonal educational resource created for this year's Open Enrollment period. It's also a glimpse into how Justworks is exploring new ways to make benefits easier to navigate with AI. Building on its live MCP capabilities for employers, Justworks is developing additional AI-powered experiences to help employees better understand their benefits, explore coverage options and navigate care.
Ready to Take on Planxiety? You don't need to have all the answers to make a more informed benefits decision. Explore The Planxiety Help Desk and choose how you'd like to get started — build a personalized AI prompt in a few clicks or download the AI Skill for more guided support.
The Planxiety Help Desk is a seasonal educational resource for employees evaluating traditional employer-sponsored group health plans. It does not recommend specific plans or provide medical, legal or tax advice. AI-generated information may contain errors or inaccuracies. Users should verify important information against official plan documents and with their employer or insurance carrier.
*Survey Methodology
This survey was conducted online within the United States by The Harris Poll on behalf of Justworks from November 3-4, 2026, among 2,014 adults ages 18 and older. The sampling precision of Harris online polls is measured by using a Bayesian credible interval. For this study, the sample data is accurate to within +/- 2.7 percentage points using a 95% confidence level. This credible interval will be wider among subsets of the surveyed population of interest. For complete survey methodology, including weighting variables and subgroup sample sizes, please contact justworks@smallgirlspr.com.
Looking for more?
Scale your business and build your team — no matter which way it grows. Access the tools, perks, and resources to help you stay compliant and grow in all 50 states.
